Post Your Opinion
by Paul Stuewe

GIVEN THE VIGOUR andvariety of the area it surveys, , edited by Irena R. Makaryk Encyclopedia of Contemporary Literary Theory:Approaches, Scholars, Terms (University of Toronto, 656 pages, $39.95 paper), very sensibly abjures completeness andaims only to "suggest something of the immense scope of currenttheoretical approaches." This its 170 contributors certainly do, and inthe process clarify many a problematic concept while occasionally running afoulof some roughish intellectual weather. Entries are organized by"Approaches," "Scholars," and "Terms," and areconscientiously cross-referenced. The absence of an index I however,means that anything not given a separate entry must be searched for underlikely-seeming headings. As a result, readers interested in irony orJacques Derrida can very easily find the corresponding entries, whereas thoseseeking information about displacement or Gerald Graff, say, have a much moredifficult task awaiting them. Standards ofaccuracy and comprehensibility are generally high. Victor Shea`s treatments ofthe "New Historicism" and "Jonathan Culler," to cite twoexamples among many, ably represent the kind of knowledgeable, literatediscourse that is often on display here. A few of the entries, including thoseon discourse analysis theory, the Frankfurt School, and narratology, fail tocome completely to grips with their subjects, and there are others that takeoblique approaches -- considering essentialism only in a feministcontext, sneaking thematic criticism in through the back door of a discussionof the "Poetics of Expressivencss" -- that render themless than satisfactory. One must also endure periodic bursts of criticaljargon, as when Margaret Atwoods Surfacing is characterizedas an attempt "to inscribe a polyphonic discourse that reflects thesplitting of the feminine subject" -- something that many ofits readers will have noted in somewhat less pretentious terms. By and large, however,the Encyclopedia is a useful and rewardingaddition to the literary reference shelf, and with some revision and periodic updatingcould well become one of the standard works in what is becoming an increasinglycrowded field.

Home First Novel Award Past Winners Subscription Back Issues Timescroll Advertizing Rates
Amazon.ca/Books in Canada Bestsellers List Books in Issue Books in Department About Us