| A Review of: No Dogs Allowed by Olga SteinThis book I loved. A team effort from Sonia Manzano (Maria of Sesame
Street fame) and illustrator Jon J. Muth, it's all about family-in
this instance an extended, close-knit Hispanic family, full of
characters instantly recognizable and endearing. The plot is simple,
but appealing. Iris's parents, sister, and dog, are to join other
family members as well as friends on a trip to the State Park lake.
The resulting cavalcade of people and cars is pure chaos, but Iris
has no difficulty navigating this sea of family members. She has
linked each person with a positive quality-like cousins "Marta
the Smart", "Carmen the Beautiful", and "Aunt
Tuta the Happily Married and her Brand-new Husband Juan"-as a
means of orienting herself amid this multitude. She isn't stereotyping
exactly-she, like every child, is imposing order on her personal
universe. We understand that hers is a child's view of things, but
it's a view we can easily adopt because her universe is comforting
in its loving depiction of people, and its underlying stability.
Iris may not be from a wealthy family, but she is in every way a
healthy, happy child, made secure by observing and partaking in
strong familial bonds.
After a couple of minor contretemps along the way, the group finally
arrives at the lake only to discover that Iris's dog, El Exigente,
isn't allowed on the beach. And what do you think happens then:
"So that day, in the parking lot of the Enchanted State Park,
my dog had his fur done by Carmen; was read to by Marta; was fed
by Don Joe; was baby-sat by my Aunt Tuta and her husband, Juan;
played dominoes with the Wise Old People; had his paw read by my
sister; and was hugged and kissed by me until...it was time to
leave."
|